Finder's Keepers? NEED HELP!?

If it feels wrong, take a step back and look over the situation as a passerby. A relationship should feel wonderful and free and make you feel happy and joyful. If you feel guilty then something's wrong. You are going to have to figure out what that is and then decide what to do about it. Yes, it is a mess you're in, but if anyone can get yourself out, it's you, because you care about these two guys and don't want them to get hurt. You're someone's girlfriend now but that doesn't mean you're anyone's puppet. Think logically and then see what your heart is saying.